A collection of unethical designs from around the world, curated by the Design Ethics SIG of the Design Research Society.

Home

Project Info

Search:

A collection of unethical designs from around the world, curated by the Design Ethics SIG of the Design Research Society.

A collection of unethical designs from around the world, curated by the Design Ethics SIG of the Design Research Society.

Home

Info

Search:

Insensitive Design

Bookcase murals that cover doorways in dementia care. This is one example of insensitivity towards a particular set of ‘users’.

In some residential care environments, design prevents harm and provides a safe environment for residents with dementia. However, some design features are deceptive or infantilizing, impacting residents’ dignity and well-being. For instance, murals are a typical design used to disguise exit doors. Motifs/ patterns such as bookcases can confuse some residents when they recognize the function of the door and the flat 2-D image of the books yet witness people walking in and out of the bookcase. Further, when others without dementia or an early stage of dementia witness residents perceiving the bookcase as real, this contributes to the paternalism and stigmatization of people with dementia. Not only are these murals dated and condescending, but they also do not recognize the capacity/ capabilities of people with dementia. Future designs should be more modern, interactive, and suited to the diverse interests of an adult population.

Keywords:

Healthcare, Insensitivity

Submitted by

Jodi Sturge

Assistant Professor, University of Twente

The Netherlands

Submitted on

April 13, 2023

This was one example of unethical design.

View more examples

Share your own!

Have you come across an an example of unethical design? (It may be a physical product, an app, a service, a space, an entire system, or even something else altogether.)

The button below will take you to a Submission Form. Once you submit your entry, the members from the DRS's Design Ethics SIG will review your entry, and then add it to this website's collection.

Share your own!

Have you come across an an example of unethical design? (It may be a physical product, an app, a service, a space, an entire system, or even something else altogether.)

The button below will take you to a Submission Form. Once you submit your entry, the members from the DRS's Design Ethics SIG will review your entry, and then add it to this website's collection.

Share your own!

Have you come across an an example of unethical design? (It may be a physical product, an app, a service, a space, an entire system, or even something else altogether.)

The button below will take you to a Submission Form. Once you submit your entry, the members from the DRS's Design Ethics SIG will review your entry, and then add it to this website's collection.