A collection of unethical designs from around the world, curated by the Design Ethics SIG of the Design Research Society.

Home

Project Info

Search:

A collection of unethical designs from around the world, curated by the Design Ethics SIG of the Design Research Society.

A collection of unethical designs from around the world, curated by the Design Ethics SIG of the Design Research Society.

Home

Info

Search:

Exclusively Digital Sales of Public Transport Ticketing

Ticket offices closed and ticket machines removed from railway stations as the majority of passengers buy tickets on the web or via apps.

The photograph shows the vinyl applied to the glass doors and windows of the former SJ ticket office at Stockholm Central Station. SJ is a government-owned passenger train operator in Sweden, and the largest passenger train company by journeys, passengers and turnover. In 2021, the last three remaining staffed railway ticket offices in Sweden were closed in Stockholm, Gothenburg and Malmö. Since then the last remaining SJ ticket machines (one is in the photograph) have also been removed.

While other operators exist, they too have moved to digital platforms for the sale of tickets. In Sweden, the implicit expectation is that transport tickets are bought online, either via web or smartphone apps, using a debit card, credit card, or the (Sweden-only) digital payment service Swish.

One can still buy tickets from convenience shops, but only in larger towns and cities in the more populous southern part of the country and always for a 100SEK (€10) premium. Bus and tram tickets cannot be bought for cash, and purchases made on board, at the point of inspection, are usually more expensive.

Passengers without access or the ability to use these technologies, or passengers without access to these digital banking services are penalised. People escaping violence or conflict, people without a permanent address — and even tourists with certain foreign banking services — are all penalised. Passengers seeking assistance in stations are directed towards roaming employees who may (or may not) be found on stations.

Author's reflection:

Sweden was one of the first countries to liberalise its railways, inviting competition between private operators and the state-owned SJ. Sweden has also embraced digitisation in many aspects of daily life, and is one of the most cashless societies in the world. But in the process, those without access to (or with physical or mental differences that prevent use of) these technologies are excluded. The safety and reassurance of an easily identifiable point-of-contact in major stations has been lost, and as a result the experience of collective transit has been affected.

Seen in:

Sweden

Keywords:

Public Transport, Hostile Design, Free-market Dynamics

Submitted by

James Benedict Brown

Associate Professor, Umeå University

Sweden

Submitted on

March 6, 2024

This was one example of unethical design.

View more examples

Share your own!

Have you come across an an example of unethical design? (It may be a physical product, an app, a service, a space, an entire system, or even something else altogether.)

The button below will take you to a Submission Form. Once you submit your entry, the members from the DRS's Design Ethics SIG will review your entry, and then add it to this website's collection.

Share your own!

Have you come across an an example of unethical design? (It may be a physical product, an app, a service, a space, an entire system, or even something else altogether.)

The button below will take you to a Submission Form. Once you submit your entry, the members from the DRS's Design Ethics SIG will review your entry, and then add it to this website's collection.

Share your own!

Have you come across an an example of unethical design? (It may be a physical product, an app, a service, a space, an entire system, or even something else altogether.)

The button below will take you to a Submission Form. Once you submit your entry, the members from the DRS's Design Ethics SIG will review your entry, and then add it to this website's collection.